Monday, November 16, 2026
Can We Still Ask Questions?
By Dale Jodoin
Columnist
Have you ever read something that helped put words to a feeling you had carried around for a while? That happened to me recently. I had been trying to understand why so many public discussions seem to leave us angry, divided and no closer to an answer.
Then I came across a study called The Rise and Fall of Rationality in Language. Quite a mouthful for something to bring to the coffee table, I know.
But stay with me. There is something here worth talking about.
The researchers looked at language in millions of books published between 1850 and 2019. They found that words connected with reasoning became more common until around 1980. After that, language connected with feelings and personal experience gained ground. The change picked up around 2007.
It made me pause. How often do we hear something now and immediately decide how we feel about it, before we know much about what happened?
I am not putting myself above anybody here.
A headline can get under my skin too. Especially when it touches family, fairness or the country I care about. Once that happens, it takes a little effort to stop and ask whether I have the whole story.
The study cannot tell us that everyone has stopped thinking. It measures language, not the honesty of every person using it.
But it helped me put a question into words: when did feeling certain become so easy, while being certain became so difficult?
That brings me to the government, because the same question belongs there.
Ottawa has a Protecting Democracy Unit within the Privy Council Office. The government also provides guidance on spotting and countering disinformation. There is a reasonable purpose behind that. Nobody wants their parents fooled by a convincing lie or their neighbours turned against each other by a made up story.
Yet I find myself wanting to pull up another chair and ask the people offering that guidance a few questions.
How easy are you making it for us to check your own claims? Can we see the records behind a decision?
And if we cannot, will you explain why?
These are ordinary questions. Suppose a decision affects your street, your child's school or the services you rely on. You hear the announcement, but something does not add up.
Wanting an explanation does not make you unreasonable. It makes you someone who has to live with the result.
There was news this week that speaks directly to that problem.
On November 2, Canada's information regulators called for better support for smaller public bodies, including municipalities, schools and police boards, to meet their obligations to release information.
They pointed to shortages of staff, money and technology that can leave people waiting.
The problem reaches Ottawa too. In February, Information Commissioner Caroline Maynard reported that more than one in five federal access requests in the previous reporting year had missed legal deadlines.
She also identified resistance to openness.
Those are different problems, and that matters. An office short of staff needs help. An office resisting openness needs to explain itself. Calling every delay a cover up would be unfair. Accepting every delay without question would be foolish.
This is where I want more from the Liberal government. If you want Canadians to trust your guidance about information, make your own information easier to obtain. That expectation should follow whoever holds office next.
I do not think most people expect to agree with every government decision. We would settle for a straight answer and enough detail to understand how it was reached.
And perhaps that is what this study brought home to me. Our feelings tell us something matters. They cannot, by themselves, tell us what is true.
It leaves me feeling that when a government will not be open with us, it has something to hide. The people in the office work for you, the taxpayer. Asking them to explain themselves is part of holding them to that responsibility.
If they work for us, why should we have to work so hard to get an answer?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment